More Than Just a Scan: Why LOD and LOA are the Keys to a Successful Project

When a building project starts with an existing structure, the first and most critical step is understanding what's already there. For architects, engineers, and contractors, this means getting a precise digital record. While 3D laser scanning is the go-to technology, many in the industry use terms like "detail" and "accuracy" interchangeably. Understanding the crucial difference between Level of Detail (LOD) and Level of Accuracy (LOA) is the single most important factor for a project's success.

Level of Detail (LOD): Capturing the What

Think of LOD as the resolution of your digital capture. It's all about the density of the point cloud, or how many individual points are collected to represent a surface. A high LOD scan captures every fitting, ductwork, and unique architectural feature. A low LOD scan might omit smaller details if the goal is to document the overall dimensions of spaces and locations of basic elements like walls, windows and doors.

The LOD required depends entirely on the project's purpose. For example, a historical restoration project would demand a high LOD to meticulously recreate intricate carvings.

Example: High-LOD converted into a High-LOA 3D Revit Model

In contrast, a simple renovation to add an office space might only require a lower LOD to capture major walls and door openings. Getting this wrong can lead to collecting far more data than is needed, increasing costs and processing time unnecessarily.

Level of Accuracy (LOA): Capturing the How

LOA is a separate but equally critical parameter. As defined by the U.S. Institute of Building Documentation (USIBD), LOA refers to the geometric precision of the BIM model as it relates to the source point cloud data. It answers the question, "How closely do the elements in my digital model conform to the measurements in the point cloud?" LOA is a measure of the geometric tolerance or deviation, expressed in millimeters or fractions of an inch, that is permissible when translating raw scan data into a clean, usable BIM model.

A scan can have a high LOD (lots of points) but a poor LOA if the modeler fails to accurately trace the point cloud data. The result would be a dense but geometrically flawed model where the elements are not true to the actual dimensions of the structure. For any project, especially one that involves structural analysis or clash detection, a high LOA is non-negotiable. A model can have beautiful detail, but if the dimensions are off by a few inches, it's completely useless for construction.

A major caveat worth noting, while modeling accuracy (LOA) is crucial, it's built on a foundation of solid data. The inherent accuracy of the point cloud itself, determined by selecting the right scanner combined with the technician's field techniques, is the most critical starting point. If the raw data is flawed, even the most skilled modeler cannot create a reliable digital twin, making proper control measures in the field essential for any successful project. Read how our team streamlines the process in this article.

The Human Element: Why Skilled Professionals Matter

This is where the human element becomes paramount. The technology is only as good as the people who operate it.

Skilled Scan Technicians are the frontline. They are responsible for acquiring data with the required geometric precision. This means strategically placing the scanner, understanding environmental factors that can affect data quality, and executing a meticulous field plan to ensure all scans are properly registered. They are the ones who ensure the raw data is "right" from the start.

Talented Drafters and Modelers are the translators. They take the raw point cloud and transform it into a functional digital twin. They must be able to work within the project’s specific LOD while achieving the required LOA. This process requires a deep understanding of construction, design, and software to create a comprehensive BIM model that is not only a visual replica but a data-rich asset.

In the end, understanding the difference between LOD and LOA is the first step to a successful project. By clearly defining these parameters and trusting them to skilled professionals, building teams can ensure they get a precise, usable digital starting point, setting the stage for success from the ground up.

---

For more than a decade, Printeks has proudly served the Montgomery, NY community with top-notch construction printing services.

While technology may change, our commitment to customer satisfaction remains our priority.

Whether your project is local or abroad, our team provides exceptional service and competitive pricing.

Reach out today to see how we can bring our expertise to your next build.

Click Me